| 2011 Division III Men's Soccer All-Region Team | |||
| Player | Pos. | School | |
| First Team | |||
| Armin Budnjo | Striker | Mohawk Valley Community College | |
| Charlie Anderson | Striker | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Dominic Francis | Striker | Genesee Community College | |
| Pablo Ordonez | Striker | Erie Community College | |
| Reco McLaren | Midfield | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Peter Keegan | Midfield | Genesee Community College | |
| Samir Naamane | Midfield | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Hobie Ramin | Midfield | Onondaga Community College | |
| Devarr Pedlar | Defense | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Declan Brennan | Defense | Genesee Community College | |
| Martin Rodriguez | Defense | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Matt Struckle | Defense | Mohawk Valley Community College | |
| Davon Bailey | Goalie | Herkimer County Community College | |
|
Second Team |
|||
| Tim Murphy | Striker | Onondaga Community College | |
| Edem Wemene | Striker | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Cody Farrier | Striker | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Mike Raftu | Striker | Fulton-Montgomery Community College | |
| Jaime Corolissen | Striker | Cayuga Community College | |
| Bruno Gaudie-Ley | Midfield | Cayuga Community College | |
| David Gould | Midfield | Mohawk Valley Community College | |
| Dane Rawson | Midfield | North Country Community College | |
| Thomas Nocito | Midfleid | SUNY Adirondack | |
| Elliott Hockley | Defense | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Dave Spaulding | Defense | Jefferson Community College | |
| Josh Gray | Defense | Genesee Community College | |
| Will Backhouse | Defense | Cayuga Community College | |
| Jack West | Goalie | Genesee Community College | |
|
Player of the Year |
|||
| Reco McLaren | Midfield | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Coach of the Year | |||
| Pepe Aragon | Herkimer County Community College | ||