| 2011 Division III Softball All-Region Team | |||
| Player | Pos. | School | |
|
Player of the Year |
|||
| Alex Hebert | IF | Monroe Community College | |
| First Team | |||
| Alex Hebert | IF | Monroe Community College | |
| Molly McDonough | IF | Hudson Valley Community College | |
| Tayler Fravel | IF | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Britt Thivierge | IF | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Holly Frampton | OF | Corning Community College | |
| Emily Woudenberg | OF | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Samijo Scheer | OF | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Krista Oakes | P | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Ashley Snyder | P | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Maggie Mulligan | C | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Kayla Ladd | UT/DH | Herkimer County Community College | |
|
Second Team |
|||
| Olivia Tooley | IF | Herkimer County Community College | |
| Chelsea Houtenbrink | IF | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Cady Ficarro | IF | Corning Community College | |
| Daisha Kane | IF | Broome Community College | |
| Lori Pelersi | OF | Hudson Valley Community College | |
| Carly Knight | OF | Monroe Community College | |
| Angie Depew | OF | Alfred State College | |
| Emilie Rogers | P | Monroe Community College | |
| Erica Hovey | P | Jefferson Community College | |
| Brooke Radley | C | Tompkins Cortland Community College | |
| Kelly Spear | UT/DH | Monroe Community College | |
| Coach of the Year | |||
| PJ Anadio | Herkimer County Community College | ||