| 2011 Wrestling All-Region Team | |||
| Wrestler | Weight Class | School | |
| First Team | |||
| Rocco Rosso | 125 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Tim Hubbard | 133 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Vinny DiGravio | 141 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Jake Kondrlik | 149 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Mark Manganaro | 157 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Troy Ireland | 165 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Dustin Moss | 174 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Marlow Baker | 184 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Travis Taylor | 197 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Kyle Gibas | 285 | Niagara County Community College | |
|
Second Team |
|||
| Matt Yanovich | 125 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Cody Dill | 133 | Alfred State College | |
| Tim Coughlin | 141 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Tyler Peet | 149 | Alfred State | |
| Dylan Freedman | 157 | Jamestown Community College | |
| Jake Hyldahl | 165 | Jamestown Community College | |
| Tony Lisek | 174 | Jamestown Community College | |
| Paul Ciaramella | 184 | Niagara County Community College | |
| Taylor Nelson | 197 | Alfred State College | |
| Joe Welton | 285 | Mercyhurst North East | |
| Coach of the Year | |||
| Eric Knuutila | Niagara County Community College | ||